In the dynamic world of mutual funds, investors frequently grapple with a fundamental question: should they invest in New Fund Offerings (NFOs) or opt for established mutual fund schemes? While each choice has its advantages, understanding the specific characteristics and trends of these options in the Indian mutual fund industry is essential for making a well-informed decision. Let’s dive into the details, backed by recent examples, to help clarify this often-debated topic.
Understanding NFOs and Existing Mutual Fund Schemes
An NFO, or New Fund Offering, is a new mutual fund scheme introduced by an asset management company (AMC). Think of an NFO like an IPO in the stock market: it’s an opportunity to buy units of a new fund at its launch price, usually ₹10. NFOs are often launched to capture an investment theme or respond to market trends. For example, in India, NFOs have surged in the environmental and social responsibility sector with funds like SBI’s ESG Fund, designed to align with environmental, social, and governance (ESG) principles.
In contrast, existing mutual fund schemes are well-established funds with a performance track record. These funds allow investors to review historical data and make decisions based on past performance, which helps assess risk, returns, and volatility. For instance, the HDFC Top 100 Fund, with a strong large-cap focus, has a lengthy history and has demonstrated performance through different market cycles, providing valuable insights for risk-averse investors.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Between NFOs and Existing Mutual Funds
| Factors |
NFO (New Fund Offering) |
Existing Mutual Fund Schemes |
| Track Record |
No historical performance data; investors rely on fund manager's vision and AMC’s reputation |
Established performance history, showcasing returns across market cycles |
| Investment Theme |
Often launched to capture new or niche themes (e.g., ESG, tech, EVs); appeals to trend-conscious investors |
Existing funds are adaptable and diversified; fund managers can incorporate trending themes within portfolio |
| Initial NAV |
Launched at a base price, typically ₹10, regardless of market conditions |
NAV reflects the fund’s market value and accumulated growth, making it an indicator of fund's journey |
| Type of Fund |
Typically thematic or sector-focused; some closed-end funds (e.g., tax-saving NFOs) may have a lock-in period |
Open-ended, closed-ended, and interval funds available, providing options based on investor preference |
| Expense Ratio |
Often higher in initial years due to setup costs and portfolio building |
Usually lower due to larger AUM and economies of scale |
| Liquidity |
Limited; closed-end NFOs may have lock-in periods; open-ended NFOs have limited initial liquidity |
High liquidity, especially in open-ended funds with easy entry and exit based on NAV |
| Entry/Exit Loads |
Initial entry load may apply; exit load may be higher for early withdrawals |
Transparent load structure; some schemes offer zero load or lower exit load after a specified period |
| Minimum Investment Amount |
Typically requires a higher minimum initial investment amount |
Many schemes offer SIP options with lower minimum investment requirements |
| Tax Efficiency |
Similar to existing funds; certain NFOs, like ELSS, offer tax deductions under Section 80C |
Established ELSS funds also provide Section 80C benefits; long-term capital gains tax applies based on NAV growth |
| Fund Manager Expertise |
Relies heavily on fund manager’s vision; AMC reputation plays a key role |
Fund manager’s expertise is observable through past performance in various market conditions |
| Risk Factor |
Higher due to lack of performance data; reliant on theme success and fund manager’s strategic approach |
Lower as performance data provides insights into risk, volatility, and fund stability |
| Investor Suitability |
Ideal for long-term, risk-tolerant investors interested in niche sectors or themes |
Suitable for conservative, moderate, or balanced investors seeking stability and proven returns |
| Portfolio Composition |
Often sector- or theme-specific, with concentrated holdings; may lack diversification in early stages |
Diversified, with balanced sectoral exposure; fund composition adapts based on market conditions |
| Flexibility and Adaptability |
Generally rigid in theme or sector due to focus; less adaptable to market changes outside its core theme |
High adaptability, especially in flexicap and multicap funds which adjust allocations across sectors |
| Transparency |
Limited visibility in initial stages, as portfolio is built after launch |
Complete transparency in holdings, returns, and asset allocation data accessible |
| Performance Benchmarking |
No past performance for benchmarking; relies on AMC’s projected expectations and market potential |
Benchmarked against established indices; historical returns can be compared against index performance |
| Timing of Entry |
Timing of NFO launch is critical as market conditions impact initial performance |
Suitable for any market phase; long-term investors benefit from rupee-cost averaging in SIP options |
Current Trends and Investor Approach
With a growing interest in sectoral and thematic NFOs in India, investors have shown a preference for funds targeting growth areas such as technology, infrastructure, and sustainable energy. However, traditional large-cap and flexicap funds continue to attract risk-averse investors who value performance stability and transparency. Let’s look at how different investor types approach these options:
1. Risk-Tolerant Investors: Those with a high-risk tolerance and a long-term horizon may consider NFOs in high-growth areas. For instance, investors drawn to Nippon India Taiwan Equity Fund, an NFO focused on high-tech sectors in Taiwan, might view this as an opportunity for significant returns. However, they should be prepared for potential short-term volatility given the sector and geographic focus.
2. Risk-Averse Investors: Conservative investors, on the other hand, often prefer existing funds like Franklin India Prima Fund, which has a well-documented track record of capital appreciation in the small- and mid-cap space. The fund’s performance data provides a level of assurance that NFOs typically cannot match.
3. Diversification Seekers: Investors with an already diversified portfolio may use NFOs to gain exposure to specific sectors or themes. For instance, if one already holds a core portfolio of diversified funds, they might add SBI Multicap Fund (initially launched as an NFO) to capture growth across large, mid, and small-cap segments in different market phases.
4. Value-Driven Investors: Market conditions can influence the appeal of NFOs. For example, when equity markets are booming, NFOs focusing on niche or underrepresented sectors like ICICI Prudential Passive Multi-Asset Fund of Fund (combining equities, debt, and gold) can attract investors seeking diversified exposure without overpaying in an overvalued equity market.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice
Deciding between an NFO and an existing mutual fund scheme ultimately depends on your investment goals, risk tolerance, and market outlook. NFOs offer investors an exciting opportunity to capture emerging trends but come with higher risks due to the lack of performance history. Established mutual funds, on the other hand, offer a proven track record and a more predictable risk-return profile, making them a safer option.
A balanced approach can work well for most investors. Allocating a smaller portion to promising NFOs in growth-oriented sectors while maintaining a core portfolio in established funds can strike the right balance. This strategy offers the potential for higher returns through NFOs while benefiting from the reliability and stability of existing mutual funds.
In essence, NFOs and existing funds can both serve as valuable components of a well-rounded portfolio. By assessing your financial goals, risk appetite, and investment horizon, you can align your mutual fund choices to create a strategy tailored to your unique needs in the ever-evolving Indian market.
Discalimer!
The content provided in this blog article is for educational purposes only. The information presented here is based on the author's research, knowledge, and opinions at the time of writing. Readers are advised to use their discretion and judgment when applying the information from this article. The author and publisher do not assume any responsibility or liability for any consequences resulting from the use of the information provided herein. Additionally, images, content, and trademarks used in this article belong to their respective owners. No copyright infringement is intended on our part. If you believe that any material infringes upon your copyright, please contact us promptly for resolution.