Don’t Be a Victim of IPO Hype: A Practical Guide for Retail Investors

Brokerage Free Team •November 22, 2025 | 5 min read • 5 views

Every year, India witnesses a wave of IPO excitement—oversubscription numbers, bumper listings, and social media frenzy. Retail investors queue up, hoping to catch the “next big multibagger.”
But beneath this hype lies a harsh truth:

Most IPOs are priced for promoters and private equity exits—not for your returns.
And while SEBI ensures transparency and regulatory compliance, it does not protect you from overvaluation.

In today’s overheated market, the responsibility of identifying overpriced IPOs rests entirely on your shoulders.

Why IPOs Are Getting More Expensive

The recent bull market has emboldened promoters and investment bankers to push valuations aggressively. As long as investors apply blindly, IPOs continue to get pricier.

What’s driving inflated valuations?

  1. Heavy Offer for Sale (OFS)
    Promoters and early investors want to exit at peak valuations.
    Example: A consumer brand IPO in 2023 had 90% OFS, raised no fresh capital, and fell 35% within 6 months post-listing.

  2. Anchor investor hype
    Institutions receive negotiated terms, creating artificial confidence that retail investors misinterpret as “smart money.”

  3. Sentiment-driven pricing
    GMP (Grey Market Premium), influencers, and advertisements fuel herd behaviour, not rational investing.

IPOs today are more about capturing maximum value for sellers than offering meaningful upside to buyers.

The Misconception: “SEBI Approved It, So It Must Be Fair”

A widespread myth among retail investors is that SEBI screens IPOs for fair pricing.
This is incorrect.

SEBI’s job: Ensure proper disclosure
Your job: Evaluate fairness of valuation

SEBI only ensures companies provide accurate, complete information.
It does not judge whether a company worth ₹500 crore is trying to list at ₹2,500 crore.

In other words, the IPO market today is a “buyer beware” ecosystem.

Why Retail Investors Often Lose Money in IPOs

Despite a few high-profile winners, a large chunk of IPOs underperform once the initial euphoria fades.

Common reasons:

  • Profit growth doesn’t sustain after listing

  • Margins compress due to competition

  • Post-listing selling pressure from early investors

  • Overpricing leaves zero margin for upside

  • IPO window-dressing inflates short-term numbers

  • Retail investors enter without understanding the business

A telling fact: Over 50% of IPOs from 2021–2023 trade below their issue price today.

How to Identify an IPO Trap

1. Beware of IPOs Dominated by OFS

If 60–80%+ of the IPO is OFS, it signals promoter exits—not growth funding.

Example:
Nykaa had a large OFS portion, and after the initial pop, the stock corrected sharply as early investors exited aggressively.

Rule: Prefer IPOs where fresh issue is used for expansion, debt reduction, or capex.

2. Compare Valuations with Listed Peers

Never buy an IPO without comparing its P/E, EV/EBITDA or Price-to-Sales with established players.

Example:
A logistics tech startup with thin margins comes at P/E 85, while Blue Dart trades at P/E 60 with better profitability.
This is an immediate red flag.

Rule: If the IPO demands a higher valuation than category leaders, skip it.

3. Detect Temporary Profit Spikes

Companies often show dramatic revenue jumps 1–2 years before IPOs—usually unsustainable.

Example:
A manufacturing firm showed revenues doubling before the IPO but flat operating margins.
Post-listing, reality caught up and the stock crashed 40%.

Rule: Analyse 5-year performance, not the last 2 years.

4. Avoid “Too Complicated” Narratives

If you can’t explain the business in two simple sentences, avoid investing.

Example:
Fintech IPOs often use jargon like AI-led ecosystems. But beneath the buzzwords, many are simply loss-making lending platforms.

Rule: Stick to transparent, predictable business models.

5. Don’t Rely on GMP (Grey Market Premium)

GMP measures speculation—not real value.

Example:
An IPO showing ₹150 GMP listed at below issue price after a single overnight global market correction.

Rule: Ignore GMP. Focus on fundamentals.

6. Check Cash Flow, Not Just Profit

Profits can be manipulated. Cash flow rarely lies.

Example:
A retail chain posted ₹120 crore profit but had three years of negative operating cash flow—a sign of aggressive credit sales.
Stock fell after listing.

Rule: Profits + cash flow growth = healthy IPO.

7. Be Cautious of Euphoria-Driven Listings

If an IPO lists with an 80–100% premium, avoid chasing the price.

Example:
Paytm listed at euphoric valuations.
Anyone who bought at listing still hasn’t recovered capital.

Rule: If you missed allotment, wait 2–3 quarters.

8. Look for Clear Use of Funds

If the RHP says “general corporate purposes” for a large chunk—be cautious.

Example:
Quality IPOs break down exactly how funds will be used:

  • new capacity

  • debt repayment

  • R&D expansion

  • acquisitions

Rule: Clarity of fund usage = management transparency.

9. Check Promoter Skin in the Game

If promoters reduce stake significantly, it signals lack of long-term conviction.

Example:
A tech firm where promoters cut stake from 70% to 45% saw immediate post-listing decline due to weak confidence signals.

Rule: High post-IPO promoter holding is positive.

The Bottom Line

IPOs are not guaranteed wealth creators.
They are simply new stocks entering the market—often at valuations that benefit sellers, not buyers.

And since SEBI’s role is limited to disclosure, the responsibility of protecting your capital is now entirely on you.

Your new playbook for IPO investing:

  • Analyse deeply

  • Compare valuations

  • Ignore hype

  • Avoid complex stories

  • Focus on cash flow

  • Question OFS-heavy offerings

  • Wait for clarity if valuations seem stretched

The only real defence against overpriced IPOs is your discipline.

So the next time an IPO is marketed as “the opportunity of the decade,” pause, zoom out, and evaluate.

Because overpriced IPOs aren’t SEBI’s problem anymore—they’re yours.

Discussion